0

Say I would like to ask a question about black's options after

  1. e4 e5
  2. f4

I would tag my question as "king's gambit" (perhaps with other tags, depending on the question itself).

On the other hand, if I would like to ask the same question after

  1. f4 e5
  2. e4

I would still tag my question as "king's gambit", but I would also use the tag "bird's opening". The questions are essentially the same, the only difference is in move order. Furthermore, if I would like to attract attention from those users who are interested in bird's opening, I may even purposefully use this order and thus the tag "bird's opening" for the same queston. (Is it proper to do so?)

Another example, for

  1. d4 d5
  2. c4

I would tag "queen's gambit"; on the other hand, for

  1. c4 d5
  2. d4

I will also tag "english opening".

So should different tags be used for the same question if the move order is presented slightly differently?

2

In general to decide on the name of the opening used, you start at the end of the game and then work backwards; the first position with a well-recognized name is the one you use.

So unless your question is specifically about the move order 1.f4 e5 2.e4, that position is a King's Gambit and not a Bird Opening or From Gambit.

  • Thanks! Then the name From's Gambit will cease to exist as the position is always named King's Gambit. – Zuriel Feb 11 at 13:26
  • 1
    @Zuriel: No, 1.f4 e5 2.fxe5 d6 is still the normal From Gambit. – RemcoGerlich Feb 11 at 13:40
1

Essentially such a question would be about a certain position, which can be reached as a variation of multiple different openings. In such a case I see no harm in tagging it with more than one relevant opening tag.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .